A Mystery Dessert Steals the Spotlight at Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes’ 1587 Prime Grand Opening

Kansas City, Missouri, has been buzzing with excitement as NFL superstars Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes unveiled their highly anticipated steakhouse, 1587 Prime, located in the luxurious Loews Kansas City Hotel. The grand opening, which took place in late summer 2025, was a star-studded affair, drawing food enthusiasts, football fans, and curious locals eager to experience the modern twist on a classic American steakhouse. Named after the duo’s jersey numbers—15 for Mahomes and 87 for Kelce—the restaurant promised an upscale yet accessible dining experience, complete with premium wagyu steaks, innovative dishes, and a nod to the players’ NFL legacy. However, amidst the fanfare of sizzling steaks and curated wine lists, one unexpected detail stole the show: a mysterious dessert, not listed on the menu, appeared on just one table, sparking intrigue and speculation. When pressed for details, the chef offered only a cryptic response: “It wasn’t meant for the public…”

The Grand Opening of 1587 Prime

The opening of 1587 Prime was more than just a restaurant launch; it was a celebration of Kansas City’s love for food and football. The 10,000-square-foot, two-story venue, designed in partnership with hospitality group Noble 33, exudes sophistication with its dark wood tones, gold accents, and subtle football-inspired décor, such as leather accents reminiscent of a football’s texture and a gold ribbon ceiling installation evoking a “flag on the play.” The menu, teased in a July 2025 Instagram video, showcased indulgent offerings like wagyu smash burgers, togarashi fried chicken, shrimp diablo, and a steak flight featuring a wagyu filet, Black Angus ribeye, and Japanese New York strip. The butter tastings, including white truffle and garlic-hibiscus varieties, were a particular highlight, with Kelce and Mahomes enthusiastically praising them during a pre-opening taste test. “I could tell from the first bite that that was going to be a ‘yeah,’” Mahomes declared, while Kelce urged, “You need some of that, dog.”

The event drew a mix of local dignitaries, Chiefs players, and celebrities, with fans lining up to catch a glimpse of the star athletes. Donna Kelce, Travis’s mother, shared her excitement on social media, posting a photo outside the restaurant with the caption, “Can’t wait for Patrick’s & Travis’ steakhouse to open in the first floor of Loew’s hotel in Kansas City!!!” The atmosphere was electric, with live R&B music filling the air and an extensive wine collection—one of the largest in the state—flowing freely. Yet, amid the carefully curated menu and meticulously planned evening, an enigmatic dessert became the talk of the night.

The Mysterious Dessert

As guests savored their wagyu steaks and chop salads, a single table—rumored to be occupied by close friends or family of Kelce and Mahomes—received a dessert that wasn’t listed on the menu. Described by onlookers as an exquisite creation, the dish appeared to be a delicate, multi-layered confection, possibly involving chocolate, gold leaf, and an intricate garnish that suggested a high level of culinary artistry. Whispers spread through the dining room as servers and guests alike noticed the exclusive treat, which stood out against the menu’s known offerings like cheesecake and crème brûlée.

Curious diners and media attendees approached the chef, whose identity has not been publicly disclosed but is presumed to be the executive chef hired for the restaurant’s opening. When asked about the dessert, the chef’s response was tantalizingly vague: “It wasn’t meant for the public…” This cryptic statement only fueled speculation, with some wondering if the dessert was a special creation reserved for VIPs, a test dish for future menus, or even a personal gesture from the chef to the restaurant’s famous owners. The lack of clarity added an air of mystique to an already glamorous event, prompting social media buzz and theories about the dessert’s origins.

Social Media and Speculation

The mystery dessert quickly became a topic of discussion on platforms like X, where users speculated about its significance. One post suggested it might be a “secret dish” crafted exclusively for the opening night, with a user claiming, “I’m a chef at that place and I can confirm there were some secret dishes.” While this claim could not be verified, it added to the intrigue surrounding 1587 Prime’s culinary offerings. Others theorized that the dessert might be a nod to Kelce and Mahomes’ personal tastes—perhaps a chocolate-heavy creation for Mahomes, known for his love of junk food like Doritos and chocolate-dipped ice cream cones, or a sophisticated treat inspired by Kelce’s high-profile romance with Taylor Swift, who is no stranger to fine dining.

The dessert’s exclusivity sparked debates about whether 1587 Prime would cater primarily to elite clientele, despite Mahomes’ earlier assurances that the restaurant would remain accessible. In a March 2024 press conference, he emphasized, “We don’t want to make it too upscale, too high-priced that not everybody can go.” The appearance of an unlisted dessert at a single table raised questions about whether the restaurant would offer exclusive experiences for select guests, potentially creating a tiered dining experience.

Theories Behind the Dessert

Several theories have emerged about the mysterious dessert. One possibility is that it was a one-off creation by the chef to impress Kelce and Mahomes or their inner circle. The restaurant’s partnership with Noble 33, known for upscale establishments like Toca Madera and Mēdüzā Mediterrania, suggests a team capable of crafting bespoke dishes for high-profile guests. Another theory posits that the dessert was a trial run for a future menu item, kept off the official menu to gauge reactions before a wider release. The chef’s comment that it “wasn’t meant for the public” supports this idea, hinting at a dish still in development.

Some have speculated that the dessert could be a personal tribute, perhaps tied to Kelce’s relationship with Taylor Swift. The couple has been spotted dining at high-end restaurants like Nobu 57 and Catch, and a custom dessert could reflect Swift’s taste for luxurious, artistic culinary creations. Alternatively, it might be a playful nod to Mahomes’ love for indulgent treats, given his admitted fondness for junk food.

The Chef’s Role and Noble 33’s Vision

The chef’s reticence to discuss the dessert underscores the secrecy surrounding 1587 Prime’s culinary operations. The restaurant advertised for an executive chef with at least seven years of experience and a salary range of $90,000 to $110,000, indicating a high level of expertise. Noble 33’s involvement ensures a polished dining experience, with co-founder Tosh Berman describing the partnership with Kelce and Mahomes as a “convergence of culinary artistry, athletic prowess, community enrichment, and unmatched hospitality.” The chef’s cryptic response may reflect Noble 33’s strategy to create buzz and exclusivity, a tactic common in their other ventures.

Impact on 1587 Prime’s Launch

The mystery dessert has undeniably added intrigue to 1587 Prime’s debut, amplifying its reputation as a must-visit destination. While the menu’s known offerings—like the wagyu smash burger and steak flight—have already generated excitement, the unlisted dessert suggests that 1587 Prime may have more surprises in store. As the restaurant prepares for its first NFL season, with an official opening date still pending, the buzz around this exclusive dish ensures that it will remain a talking point among Kansas City’s food and football fans.

Conclusion

Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes have brought their winning chemistry from the football field to the dining scene with 1587 Prime, a steakhouse that promises to blend sophistication with Kansas City’s community spirit. The grand opening was a triumph, but the appearance of a mysterious, unlisted dessert stole the spotlight, leaving guests and observers eager for answers. Whether a VIP exclusive, a culinary experiment, or a personal gesture, the dessert—and the chef’s enigmatic comment—has cemented 1587 Prime as a place of intrigue and excellence. As Kansas City awaits the restaurant’s full launch, one thing is clear: 1587 Prime is more than just a steakhouse—it’s a destination where surprises, like a secret dessert, are part of the experience.