
Last week it was reported the “real life Martha” who inspired Baby Reindeer is suing Netflix in a lawsuit for £132million. Now, lawyers have said Netflix may lose the battle and have to pay up, because of a line in the first episode of the show.
The lawsuit, filed in a California court, seeks over $170million (£132million) in damages for Fiona Harvey. She has accused Netflix of spreading “brutal lies”, including that she is a “twice convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison”.
The lawsuit states: “Defendants told these lies, and never stopped, because it was a better story than the truth, and better stories made money. As a result of defendants’ lies, malfeasance and utterly reckless misconduct, Harvey’s life had been ruined.”

Fiona has previously spoken out about how she believes some of the parts of the show were made up, and weren’t actually true to fact within the story. In her interview with Piers Morgan, Fiona detailed some of the events in the show that she has claimed aren’t actually true.
Speaking to Business Insider, two entertainment lawyers have said Fiona may have a pretty solid case, based on this and one line in the first episode of the Netflix show.
A simple, five-word line appears onscreen during the first episode of the seven-part series: “This is a true story.” However, Fiona has claimed parts are not true. The lawyers have said Netflix should have instead said the drama was “based on” a true story, or “inspired by” real events.
Netflix does include a disclaimer at the end of the Baby Reindeer credits that reads: “This program is based on real events, however certain characters, names, incidents, locations, and dialogue have been fictionalised for dramatic purposes.” However, lawyers have said that this being in the credits, where a viewer may not obviously spot it, might not be enough of a defence.
According to the legal documents, Fiona has accused Netflix of defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, gross negligence, and violations of her right of publicity. She has claimed Netflix made it easy for viewers of the series to find her.
A lawyer told Business Insider if Fiona Harvey can demonstrate she was readily identifiable in the show and Netflix made up claims about her, “this is the worst type of defamation.”
Fiona Harvey is seeking $50million in actual damages from Netflix, in addition to at least $50million in compensatory damages due to “mental anguish, loss of enjoyment of life and loss of business”. She is also seeking at least $50million “for all profits from Baby Reindeer” and at least $20million in punitive damages.
A Netflix spokesperson said: “We intend to defend this matter vigorously and to stand by Richard Gadd’s right to tell his story.”
News
“FANS WAITED… THEN THE SHOW WAS SUDDENLY CANCELED” 💔🎤 Lady Gaga was forced to cancel a major concert at the last minute after a sudden health issue, leaving thousands of fans stunned. What happened backstage just before the announcement is now the detail people can’t stop talking about
Lady Gaga ‘heartbroken’ after doctor advises her to cancel concert over health issue The singer had been due to perform in Canada ahead of her return to the US Lady Gaga has expressed her deep regret and heartbreak over letting…
COACHELLA JUST GOT HIT WITH A FINE… AND IT INVOLVES A SURPRISE APPEARANCE 🎤🚨 Organizers of Coachella were reportedly fined after sets involving Justin Bieber and Anyma ran past strict curfew rules. But the exact moment that pushed the festival over the limit is the part fans say nobody expected to happen on that stage
Coachella fined $40,000 after Justin Bieber and Anyma sets broke golden rule Justin Bieber headlined Coachella, but his set has seen the music festival’s promoter landed with a hefty fine The promoter behind Coachella is facing a hefty fine after…
RISING STAR… NOW FACING MURDER CHARGE 🚨 Fans were stunned after reports surfaced that singer d4vd has been charged in connection with a murder case
“RISING STAR… NOW FACING MURDER CHARGE” 🚨 Fans were stunned after reports surfaced that singer d4vd has been charged in connection with a murder case. The news spread across social media within minutes — but one detail investigators revealed about…
“THAT’S NOT HIS REAL NAME…” 🎤 Jay-Z once revealed the real reason he chose the name that made him famous — and it goes back to the early days surrounding Reasonable Doubt
“THAT’S NOT HIS REAL NAME…” 🎤 Jay-Z once revealed the real reason he chose the name that made him famous — and it goes back to the early days surrounding Reasonable Doubt. Fans celebrating the anniversary of the classic album…
OUR LITTLE BOY WILL KNOW HOW MUCH YOU LOVED HIM: In a heartbreaking tribute, Jessica Carter Dawson remembered her husband Jaryd Dawson, who had spent the day with their baby before tragedy struck near Robe, and the last photo taken that afternoon shows something about the moment between father and son that people can’t stop talking about…
The loss of Jaryd Dawson, the thirty-five-year-old father who was discovered near a cliffside lookout outside Robe in April 2026, has left the South Australian community in a state of collective mourning. In the days following the tragedy, his wife,…
A TRIBUTE THAT LEFT FRIENDS IN TEARS. After the death of Jaryd Dawson, loved ones began sharing memories of the father who had recently welcomed a baby boy with Jessica Carter Dawson, and one quiet story about what he did the night before is now being repeated by friends…
The tragic story of Jaryd Dawson, a thirty-five-year-old father whose life reached a devastating conclusion on the rugged coastline of South Australia in April 2026, has evolved into a national narrative of grief, reflection, and the profound weight of silent…
End of content
No more pages to load