Kayleigh McEnany’s Co-Hosts Throw Surprise Baby Shower—But It Was the $8,000 Gift From Greg Gutfeld That Left Her Speechless 🎉🍼

On May 20, 2025, Fox News co-host and former White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany was surprised with an on-air baby shower during Outnumbered, celebrating her third pregnancy with husband Sean Gilmartin, a former MLB pitcher. The couple, expecting their third child—a boy named Theodore Patrick—in June, were showered with love and gifts from McEnany’s colleagues. While the heartfelt gestures from co-hosts like Harris Faulkner and Emily Compagno warmed the studio, it was a jaw-dropping $8,000 gift from Greg Gutfeld that left McEnany speechless and sparked a wave of reactions across social media.

A Surprise Celebration

Kayleigh McEnany, 36, announced her pregnancy on March 17, 2025, revealing that the addition to her family with daughter Blake, 5, and son Nash, 2, was unplanned but deeply cherished. During a gender reveal on May 15, the family confirmed they were expecting a boy, with Blake’s joyful cry, “It’s a boy!” stealing hearts. The name Theodore Patrick, chosen by Gilmartin for its historical tie to Theodore Roosevelt and family heritage, added a layer of significance to the anticipation.

The baby shower, orchestrated by McEnany’s Outnumbered co-hosts, was a complete surprise. As McEnany walked onto the set, expecting a standard segment, she was greeted with blue balloons, a “Baby Boy McEnany” banner, and a table laden with gifts. “You guys!” McEnany exclaimed, visibly moved as she hugged co-hosts Harris Faulkner, Emily Compagno, and guest co-host Dana Perino. The segment, filled with laughter and tears, resonated with viewers, who took to X with posts like, “Kayleigh’s baby shower was so sweet! Love how her Fox family is celebrating her!”

A Parade of Thoughtful Gifts

McEnany’s colleagues presented a series of gifts, each reflecting their affection and support for her growing family. The lineup included:

A Custom Baby Blanket from Harris Faulkner
Faulkner gifted a hand-stitched blue blanket embroidered with “Theodore Patrick” and a small baseball, nodding to Gilmartin’s MLB career. “This is for your little slugger to stay cozy,” Faulkner said, prompting McEnany to tear up.

A Diaper Genie Elite from Emily Compagno
Compagno, known for her humor, presented a high-tech Diaper Genie with a year’s supply of refills. “Three kids under six? You’ll thank me later,” she quipped, drawing laughs. McEnany called it a “lifesaver” for the nursery.

A Devotional Book from Rachel Campos-Duffy
Campos-Duffy, a fellow mother, gave a leather-bound devotional book for parents, inscribed with, “For Kayleigh, Sean, and Theodore—guided by faith.” McEnany, who often cites Scripture like Jeremiah 1:5, said she’d treasure it.

A Patriotic Onesie Set from Madison Alworth
Alworth gifted a set of baby onesies featuring American flags and inspirational quotes. “For your little patriot, Theodore,” she said, referencing McEnany’s love for American values.

A Spa Day Voucher from Dana Perino
Perino, a mentor, gifted a voucher for a spa day, urging McEnany to prioritize self-care. “You’re juggling so much—take time for you,” Perino said. McEnany later shared she used it to journal letters to Theodore, inspired by Luke 12:7.

A Custom Journal from Jesse Watters
Watters presented a leather-bound journal embossed with “Theodore Patrick” and a cross, inscribed with, “For the next generation of truth-tellers.” McEnany called it a “forever keepsake” for her son.

An $8,000 Nursery Rocking Chair from Greg Gutfeld
The showstopper came from Greg Gutfeld, host of Gutfeld!, who gifted an $8,000 custom-designed nursery rocking chair from a high-end boutique. The chair, upholstered in soft navy leather with Theodore’s initials carved into the armrest, was presented with Gutfeld’s signature wit: “Kayleigh, this is for those late nights when you’re rocking Theodore and watching reruns of my show.” The studio erupted in laughter, but McEnany was visibly stunned, saying, “Greg, I’m speechless—this is beyond generous.”

The Gift That Stole the Show

Gutfeld’s $8,000 rocking chair became the talk of the baby shower, not just for its price but for its thoughtful design. Crafted for comfort and durability, it featured a reclining mechanism and a built-in ottoman, perfect for late-night feedings. McEnany, still emotional, hugged Gutfeld and said, “This will be where I read Theodore his bedtime stories.” Fans on X went wild, with posts like, “Greg Gutfeld dropping $8K on a rocking chair?! That’s next-level! Congrats Kayleigh!” and “That chair is stunning—perfect for Theodore’s nursery!” The gift’s extravagance, paired with Gutfeld’s humorous delivery, made it a standout moment, trending under #McEnanyBabyShower.

A Family-Centered Journey

McEnany’s pregnancy has been marked by heartfelt moments, including her mother Leanne’s advice to “embrace the chaos,” which helped her view the unplanned pregnancy as a blessing. She’s leaned on her faith, journaling to Theodore in Watters’ gift and citing Scriptures like Luke 12:7, “God knows the very hairs on our head.” Gilmartin, who chose Theodore for its tie to Theodore Roosevelt’s legacy of courage, joined the shower via video, joking, “Greg, you’ve set the bar too high for my next Father’s Day gift!” Blake and Nash also appeared, with Blake proudly holding a “Big Sister” sign, prompting X users to post, “Blake is the star of this family!”

A Shift in Priorities

Following Theodore’s birth, McEnany announced she’d shift from full-time hosting on Outnumbered to curating long-form specials on faith, family, and politics, allowing her to “fully embrace this season of motherhood.” The decision, shared on May 20, 2025, was met with support, with hashtags like #FaithAndFamilyFirst trending. One X user wrote, “Kayleigh’s balancing career and family so gracefully—such an inspiration!” Her colleagues, including Perino, praised her choice, with Perino noting, “You’re showing women they can do both—motherhood and a career.”

A Universal Celebration

Despite McEnany’s polarizing political past, the baby shower and Gutfeld’s extravagant gift transcended divides, resonating with audiences through the universal joy of welcoming a child. X posts reflected this, with one user writing, “Politics aside, that $8,000 chair from Gutfeld is iconic. Congrats Kayleigh and Sean!” The shower highlighted the camaraderie at Fox News, with the rocking chair symbolizing the network’s support for McEnany’s growing family.

As McEnany and Gilmartin prepare to welcome Theodore Patrick, the $8,000 rocking chair stands as a testament to the love and generosity surrounding them. McEnany promised to share updates on X, including photos of Theodore in the nursery, where the chair will take pride of place. For now, the baby shower, capped by Gutfeld’s unforgettable gift, remains a heartwarming chapter in the McEnany-Gilmartin family’s story, celebrating faith, family, and the anticipation of their newest member.