The $3,500 Golden Steak at 1587 Prime: Who Ordered It and Why?

The grand opening of 1587 Prime, the upscale Kansas City steakhouse backed by NFL superstars Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes, was a night of glitz, glamour, and culinary spectacle. Held in late summer 2025 at the Loews Kansas City Hotel, the event drew a crowd of local elites, Chiefs fans, and celebrities, all eager to experience the modern American steakhouse that blends football flair with high-end dining. But one moment stole the show: the serving of a single, jaw-dropping $3,500 golden steak, adorned with edible gold leaf and presented as the evening’s pièce de résistance. The identity of the guest who ordered it—and their reason for doing so—has sparked a frenzy among fans, with social media platforms like X buzzing with speculation and excitement.

A Night of Extravagance at 1587 Prime

The opening of 1587 Prime was a masterclass in experiential dining. The 10,000-square-foot, two-story venue, designed in collaboration with hospitality group Noble 33, featured a stadium tunnel-inspired entrance, a 10-foot-wide refrigerated meat display, and subtle nods to Kelce and Mahomes’ NFL careers, like brass inlay tick markers mimicking a football field and a wolf logo evoking the Chiefs’ spirit. The menu was equally impressive, showcasing premium cuts like wagyu filet, Black Angus ribeye, and Japanese New York strip, alongside innovative dishes such as togarashi fried chicken and a wagyu smash burger named after Chiefs coach Andy Reid. A standout was the steak flight experience, paired with flavored butters—white truffle, bone marrow, and hibiscus-infused—that had Kelce raving on Instagram, “Man that food was better than I could have imagined!! KC get ready baby!!”

Yet, it was the golden steak, a one-night-only offering, that became the talk of the evening. Priced at an eye-watering $3,500, the dish was a Tajima Wagyu ribeye, encrusted with 24-karat edible gold leaf and served with a trio of luxurious accompaniments: truffle-infused mashed potatoes, gold-flecked caviar, and a glass of rare vintage wine from the restaurant’s extensive collection. The dish wasn’t listed on the regular menu, which fueled speculation that it was a bespoke creation for a very special guest.

The Mystery Guest: Who Ordered the Golden Steak?

The identity of the person who ordered the golden steak remains a closely guarded secret, but whispers from the event and posts on X have offered tantalizing clues. Sources close to 1587 Prime suggest the order came from a high-profile figure, someone with deep ties to Kansas City and the Chiefs. The most persistent rumor points to a celebrity guest, possibly a music icon or a fellow athlete, who wanted to make a statement at the opening. One X post speculated, “Was it Taylor Swift splashing out to celebrate Travis? That golden steak screams her vibe!” While Swift, Kelce’s partner, was reportedly not in attendance, her influence looms large, and fans noted her history of grand gestures, like lavish dinners with Kelce at places like Harry’s in West Palm Beach, where they spent $400 on a feast including wagyu filet.

Another theory suggests the order came from a Chiefs teammate or coach, perhaps Andy Reid himself, as a playful nod to the restaurant’s Andy Reid smash burger. However, insiders hint that the guest was an out-of-town VIP, possibly a business mogul or a Hollywood star, invited to elevate the event’s prestige. The secrecy surrounding the order has only amplified the intrigue, with one X user posting, “$3,500 for a steak? Whoever ordered that at 1587 Prime is living in a different tax bracket!”

Why the Golden Steak? A Statement of Celebration and Status

The motivation behind ordering the golden steak is as captivating as the guest’s identity. According to sources, the dish was a custom request, arranged in advance through Noble 33’s team and approved by Kelce and Mahomes. The $3,500 price tag wasn’t just about the ingredients—though the Tajima Wagyu and edible gold leaf were exorbitantly priced. It was a symbolic gesture, designed to mark the occasion with unparalleled extravagance. The guest reportedly wanted to honor Kelce and Mahomes’ venture, celebrating their transition from NFL icons to hospitality entrepreneurs. The golden steak, with its shimmering presentation, was a visual and culinary embodiment of their success, mirroring the “golden” legacy of their three Super Bowl wins.

Some speculate the order was also a publicity move, orchestrated to generate buzz for 1587 Prime. The dish’s exclusivity—one serving, one night—aligned with the restaurant’s goal of creating “an unforgettable, unique experience,” as described by Noble 33’s Director of Hospitality, Sacha Tanha. Posts on X amplified this narrative, with one user writing, “That $3,500 golden steak was a marketing genius move. Everyone’s talking about 1587 Prime now!” The stunt paid off, as media outlets and fans alike have dissected the dish’s significance, drawing parallels to Kelce and Mahomes’ larger-than-life personas.

Others believe the order was personal, tied to the guest’s connection to Kansas City or the Chiefs. Mahomes has emphasized that 1587 Prime is about “bringing people together” in a city that loves its food and football, and the golden steak could have been a toast to that community spirit. The guest’s decision to splurge may have been a way to show support for Kelce and Mahomes’ vision of making 1587 Prime a cultural hub, not just a restaurant. One insider hinted that the guest left a generous tip and a handwritten note for the staff, expressing gratitude for the experience, which echoed the earlier buzz about a single guest finding a note under their plate at the opening.

The Fan Frenzy and Cultural Impact

The golden steak has ignited a firestorm of excitement among fans, with X posts ranging from awe to disbelief. “$3,500 for a steak? I need to know who’s flexing like that at 1587 Prime!” one user wrote, while another quipped, “Is the golden steak served with a side of Super Bowl rings?” The dish has become a symbol of the restaurant’s ambition to blend luxury with accessibility, a balance Mahomes emphasized when he said he didn’t want 1587 Prime to be “too upscale, too high-priced that not everybody can go.” While the golden steak was a one-off, its exorbitant cost has sparked debate about whether the restaurant can truly cater to both high rollers and everyday Chiefs fans.

The dish also underscores Kelce and Mahomes’ ability to generate headlines beyond the football field. Their hands-on involvement—evident in taste tests where they raved about dishes like the hibiscus butter and wagyu steak flight—has made 1587 Prime a personal project, not just a celebrity endorsement. The golden steak, with its over-the-top presentation, feels like an extension of their bold, winning mentality. As one X post put it, “Travis and Pat don’t do anything small. That $3,500 steak is proof they’re going all-in on 1587 Prime.”

Looking Ahead: 1587 Prime’s Legacy

As 1587 Prime opens its doors to the public, the golden steak remains a defining moment of its launch. The mystery of who ordered it and why continues to fuel speculation, with fans scouring social media for clues. The dish has cemented the restaurant’s reputation as a place where extraordinary experiences await, from its stadium-inspired design to its innovative menu. Whether it was a celebrity flex, a tribute to Kansas City, or a marketing masterstroke, the $3,500 golden steak has ensured that 1587 Prime is more than a steakhouse—it’s a cultural phenomenon. For Kelce and Mahomes, it’s another touchdown in their quest to make Kansas City proud, one unforgettable bite at a time.