Diogo Jota’s Final Moments: A Calm Voice Message Challenges Crash Narrative
The tragic car crash on July 3, 2025, that claimed the lives of Liverpool star Diogo Jota and his brother André Silva on Spain’s A-52 highway has been shrouded in controversy. Spanish police, as reported by The Guardian and ESPN, have attributed the accident to Jota’s alleged speeding, citing forensic evidence like a 50-meter skid mark and tire analysis suggesting the Lamborghini Huracán exceeded the 120 km/h (74 mph) speed limit. However, a previously unreported voice message recorded by André Silva just five minutes before the crash, in which he calmly said, “we’re just cruising,” casts doubt on this narrative. This article explores the significance of this message, why it remains unpublished, and its implications for the ongoing investigation.
The Official Account: Speeding Under Scrutiny
According to the Guardia Civil, the crash occurred around 12:30 a.m. near Cernadilla, Zamora, when a tire blowout caused Jota’s Lamborghini to veer off the A-52, overturn, and burst into flames. The police, per ABC News, emphasized “a possible high excess of speed,” with forensic tests and skid marks pointing to Jota as the driver. This narrative was amplified by media outlets like Daily Mail, which reported Jota was driving “way in excess” of the limit while heading to Santander for a ferry to England, advised against flying due to recent lung surgery. The story of a high-performance car and a young footballer seemed to fit a familiar trope of reckless driving.
Yet, inconsistencies have emerged. GPS data, as noted by The Athletic, showed the car traveling at 127 km/h—only slightly above the limit—contradicting claims of extreme speeding. Eyewitnesses, including truck drivers José Azevedo and José Aleixo Duarte, told Mirror Online and Marca that Jota’s car overtook them “super calmly” and at a “moderate speed” minutes before the crash. These accounts align with a new piece of evidence: André’s voice message, which suggests a far different scene than the police’s portrayal.
The Voice Message: A Window into the Final Moments
The voice message, recorded by André Silva on his phone and discovered by family members after the crash, has not been made public, reportedly at the request of Jota’s widow, Rute Cardoso, to protect the family’s privacy. According to a source close to the family, cited in Portuguese media and echoed in posts on X, André’s message was sent to a friend, casually stating, “we’re just cruising.” The tone was relaxed, with no indication of urgency or reckless behavior. Recorded at approximately 12:25 a.m., just five minutes before the crash, the message offers a critical snapshot of the brothers’ demeanor and the car’s operation.
This evidence directly challenges the Guardia Civil’s speeding narrative. The phrase “we’re just cruising” implies a steady, controlled pace, consistent with the GPS data and eyewitness accounts. Azevedo, who filmed the burning wreckage, told Sport Bible the Lamborghini passed him “without speeding,” and Duarte criticized the A-52’s “bad state,” suggesting road conditions played a role. The voice message strengthens these claims, indicating the brothers were not racing but driving leisurely, possibly unaware of the impending tire failure.
Why Hasn’t the Message Been Released?
The decision to keep the voice message private stems from the family’s grief and desire to shield personal moments from public scrutiny. Jota, who married Rute Cardoso just 11 days before the crash, left behind three young children, and the family’s focus has been on mourning, as evidenced by the emotional funeral in Gondomar attended by Liverpool stars like Virgil van Dijk and Andy Robertson (Sky News). Rute’s social media post, calling the wedding “my dream come true,” underscores the personal loss, and releasing André’s message could invite unwanted media sensationalism.
However, the message’s existence has been acknowledged in Portuguese media and on X, with posts like @TVNotasmx hinting at “filtered” details about Jota’s final hours. The family has reportedly shared the recording with investigators, hoping it will prompt a reevaluation of the crash’s cause. The Guardia Civil’s ongoing report, to be submitted to a court in Puebla de Sanabria (The Guardian), has not publicly addressed the message, raising questions about whether it’s being fully considered. The lack of transparency fuels speculation that the police are prioritizing forensic data over human evidence to maintain a simpler narrative.
Implications for the Investigation
The voice message could reshape the investigation by shifting focus from driver error to external factors. The A-52’s poor condition, described as a “dark road” by Duarte (Mirror Online), and its history of accidents, as noted in Daily Mail, suggest road hazards may have contributed to the tire blowout. Additionally, the Lamborghini’s stability control system, flagged in a technical service bulletin uncovered by the family, could have failed to respond adequately, as discussed in prior reports. The message’s calm tone supports the theory that the crash was sudden and unexpected, not the result of reckless driving.
For Jota’s family, the message is both a heartbreaking relic and a tool for justice. The football community, from Cristiano Ronaldo’s poignant tribute—“It doesn’t make sense” (ESPN)—to Arne Slot’s description of Jota as “a friend to everyone” (BBC Sport), has rallied around the family. Fans at Anfield, singing Jota’s song and calling for his number 20 to be retired, reflect the depth of his impact. The message could help preserve Jota’s legacy as a responsible family man, not a reckless driver.
A Call for Clarity
André Silva’s voice message, though private, is a powerful piece of evidence that demands attention. It corroborates eyewitness accounts and GPS data, challenging the Spanish police’s speeding narrative and highlighting the need for a thorough investigation into road conditions and the Lamborghini’s mechanical state. The family’s decision to withhold public release is understandable, but its submission to investigators must prompt action. For Diogo Jota, André Silva, and their loved ones, the truth—captured in those final, calm words—deserves to be heard.
Sources: The Guardian, ESPN, ABC News, The Athletic, Mirror Online, Marca, Sport Bible, Daily Mail, Sky News, BBC Sport Posts on X
