In the emotionally charged sentencing phase of Tanner Horner’s capital murder trial, the family of 7-year-old Athena Strand has shared raw, heartbreaking testimony about the enduring pain of losing their vibrant little girl. As jurors weigh whether Horner — the former FedEx driver who pleaded guilty to her 2022 abduction, kidnapping, and murder — should receive the death penalty or life without parole, Athena’s loved ones described a grief that lingers in everyday moments: the phantom sounds of her laughter, the vivid mental images that appear the moment they close their eyes, and the aching quiet that has replaced the joyful noise of a once-lively household.

Athena Strand, a bright-eyed first-grader known for her energy, smile, and love of simple country pleasures like riding four-wheelers, was taken on November 30, 2022, from her family’s rural home in Paradise, Texas. She had been sorting laundry in a converted shed serving as a temporary bedroom during home renovations when Horner arrived to deliver a Christmas package. What should have been a routine day ended in unimaginable tragedy.

foxnews.com

nbcdfw.com

A Family’s Lasting Void

Athena’s stepmother, Ashley (Elizabeth Ashley) Strand, took the stand in tears, recounting the frantic moments after realizing Athena was missing and the devastating phone call confirming her death. She described how the family’s life changed forever: “I lost it. I’m not the same.” Ashley spoke of her other daughter now running and hiding at the sight of delivery drivers, a stark reminder of how trauma has reshaped even the smallest routines.

Athena’s biological mother, Maitlyn Gandy, and father, Jacob Strand, have also expressed profound grief in public statements and through family representatives. One parent captured the haunting nature of memory: “If I close my eyes, I can still see her…” They noted that memories feel simultaneously close — etched sharply in the mind — and painfully unreachable, as the little girl who filled their days with sound and light is gone.

The hardest part, one family member shared, is not the current silence in the home, but the vivid recollection of what life used to sound like: Athena’s giggles, her chatter while playing, the everyday chaos of a happy child. That contrast — between the joyful noise that once defined their world and the heavy quiet that followed — has become a daily source of heartbreak.

nbcdfw.com

nbcdfw.com

Testimony Amid the Sentencing Phase

The punishment phase, which began after Horner’s surprise guilty plea in early April 2026, has featured intense victim impact statements alongside forensic details and Horner’s own jailhouse writings. Jurors heard letters Horner wrote to Athena’s family expressing remorse (“I’m sorry I took your little angel away from you. She didn’t deserve it. Y’all didn’t deserve it”), while also noting his shifting narratives, including references to an “alter ego” and mental health struggles presented by the defense.

Prosecutors have emphasized the brutality of the crime, including evidence from the FedEx truck and the recovery of Athena’s clothing near Horner’s shed. Family testimony has underscored the human cost: a child full of life, dreams, and innocence stolen during what should have been a festive season.

wfaa.com

wfaa.com

Athena’s funeral featured a custom pink casket with her photo, Disney songs, and tributes reflecting her personality — a final, colorful farewell that stood in painful contrast to the darkness of her final hours.

The Trial Context

Horner, 34 at the time of sentencing proceedings, has faced accusations of attempting to break Athena’s neck before strangling her and disposing of her body near the Trinity River. A haunting image shown in court reportedly captured Athena alive inside his delivery truck shortly after the abduction. Defense arguments have centered on Horner’s claimed mental health issues, autism spectrum disorder, and diminished culpability, seeking to avoid the death penalty.

Jail calls and letters presented in court revealed Horner’s fluctuating emotions — from joking to crying — and his mother’s shocked reactions during early conversations. The Strand family, meanwhile, has focused on honoring Athena’s memory and seeking accountability.

keranews.org

nbcdfw.com

A Community Still Healing

The Wise County community rallied during the initial search for Athena, with volunteers, law enforcement, and technology aiding the effort. Her death highlighted vulnerabilities in rural areas and raised questions about delivery safety protocols. Supporters continue to remember Athena as a fighter — brave, bold, and deeply loved.

As the jury deliberates Horner’s fate in mid-April 2026, Athena’s family carries forward with memories that both comfort and wound. The silence in their home is not empty; it echoes with what was lost.

“If I close my eyes, I can still see her…” These words from Athena’s parents speak to a grief that time does not easily soften. They reflect the universal pain of parents who must navigate a world without their child’s voice, laughter, or presence — yet keep her spirit alive through remembrance.

Rest in peace, sweet Athena. Your family’s strength and love for you shine through even the darkest days. The quest for justice continues in your name.