🚨 UNEXPECTED MOVEMENT: Nancy Guthrie’s Mailbox Has Just Been Opened, But What Surprised Them Most Was Letter Number 3
The disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of NBC “Today” show co-host Savannah Guthrie, continues to unfold with dramatic and troubling developments in Tucson, Arizona. As the investigation enters its second week, reports of a mailbox being opened at her Catalina Foothills home have surfaced, drawing immediate attention from authorities and the public. The discovery inside—specifically “letter number 3″—has intensified speculation, though official confirmation remains limited and details are emerging cautiously amid a flood of ransom-related communications.
Nancy Guthrie was reported missing on February 1, 2026, after family members found her absent from her home following a family dinner the previous evening. She was last seen around 9:48–9:50 p.m. on January 31 when her son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, dropped her off after driving her home. Surveillance footage captured her garage door opening and closing shortly after. The scene quickly turned concerning: blood drops on the porch matched her DNA, signs of possible forced entry were noted, and her Nest doorbell camera had been disconnected around 1:47 a.m. on February 1, with motion detected later at 2:12 a.m. Her pacemaker app disconnected around 2:28 a.m., adding urgency to fears of abduction.
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos and the FBI have treated the case as a suspected kidnapping, emphasizing that Nancy may still be alive. A $50,000 reward is offered for information leading to her recovery or the arrest of those responsible. Investigators have conducted multiple sweeps of the property, towing a vehicle from the garage for forensic analysis and removing a previously undetected camera from the roof. No suspects or persons of interest have been publicly named, though authorities stress that no one has been ruled out.
The ransom communications have complicated the probe. Multiple media outlets, including TMZ, KOLD, and others, received purported ransom notes demanding millions in cryptocurrency (Bitcoin), with deadlines such as Thursday evening (February 5) and a follow-up on Monday (February 9). One note included details purportedly known only to the abductor, such as crime scene specifics. An imposter, Derrick Callella from California, was arrested for sending a fake demand. Authorities described at least one note as “structured” and potentially credible, though none provided verifiable proof of life—a critical concern for the family.
The family, including Savannah Guthrie and siblings Annie and Charles Cameron, issued emotional pleas via Instagram, acknowledging the ransom reports and urging direct contact with undeniable proof that Nancy is alive. “We need to know without a doubt that she is alive and that you have her,” Savannah said, highlighting her mother’s fragile health, constant pain, and need for medication.
In this context, the mailbox discovery has fueled online speculation and breaking-news alerts. Reports suggest that “letter number 3” was found when the mailbox in front of Nancy’s home was opened—possibly by law enforcement or family during a follow-up check—prompting surprise and renewed scrutiny. This appears to align with recent mentions of a “new message” or additional note received by local media (such as KOLD on February 6), which investigators are analyzing for authenticity. The note reportedly lacked proof of life, new demands, or traceable contact methods, sent via an untraceable service similar to prior communications.
Sheriff Nanos addressed related rumors, calling some reporting “reckless” while confirming active review of new information. A February 6 update noted deputies returning to the home after a “new message” surfaced, with FBI teams conducting searches. Social media posts and news outlets have linked this to escalating developments, including the towed SUV, roof camera seizure, and concerns over Nancy’s medication and well-being.
The “third letter” reference may indicate the third in a series of ransom-style messages—following initial notes to TMZ and local stations—though not all have been verified as from the same source. Authorities have warned against hoaxes bogging down the investigation, with one fake demand already leading to an arrest. No official statement has explicitly confirmed a physical letter in the mailbox as a breakthrough, but the timing coincides with heightened activity at the property and public pleas for credible leads.
As the search intensifies, focus remains on forensic evidence, digital analysis, and public tips. Neighbors reported prior trespassing concerns, and authorities continue urging anyone with information to contact the tip line. The absence of proof of life in communications heightens anxiety, with experts noting that time is critical given Nancy’s age and health needs.
The Guthrie family holds out hope, repeatedly stating their readiness to engage directly. Until authorities confirm details of the mailbox find or “letter number 3,” it remains part of the evolving narrative in this high-profile case. Prayers and support continue nationwide for Nancy’s safe return.
