Leaked Fan Theory: The “6 Accidental Touches” That Have Nicogab Shippers Dissecting Every Frame of Culpa Nuestra—With Gabriel Guevara’s Girlfriend in the Crosshairs

In the feverish world of fan theories, where a single frame can unravel into hours of debate, the Culpables fandom has struck gold—or dynamite—with a leaked analysis claiming Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara shared exactly six “accidental touches” during the filming of Their Fault (Culpa Nuestra). Penned by an anonymous superfan on a gossip page called “CulpaConfessions” (a notorious hub for trilogy tea on Threads and Reddit), the breakdown meticulously timestamps behind-the-scenes clips, zooming in on moments where hands brushed, shoulders grazed, or fingers lingered just a beat too long. “These aren’t choreographed intimacy scenes; these are unscripted sparks,” the post declares, complete with annotated screenshots and slow-mo GIFs. But here’s the scandalous kicker: with Guevara firmly coupled with actress María de Nati, every alleged glance and graze feels like a betrayal in waiting, turning innocent set camaraderie into a powder keg of heartbreak for shippers obsessed with the #Nicogab endgame.

The theory exploded onto X last week, amassing over 1.2 million views in 48 hours under hashtags like #AccidentalTouches and #CulpaSecrets. Posted initially on a private Discord server before leaking to the gossip page, the analysis—titled “The Touches That Tell: Nicogab’s Unspoken Truth”—breaks down the six instances across reshoots in Madrid’s sweltering summer of 2025. Number one: a 2:14 mark in a leaked rehearsal clip where Guevara’s hand “accidentally” steadies Wallace’s waist during a spin, her laugh trailing off into a lingering eye-lock. “Not in the blocking—pure instinct,” the theorist notes. By touch six—a subtle finger-trace along her arm in a group huddle—the post spirals into Freudian territory: “These aren’t accidents; they’re echoes of Noah and Nick refusing to let go.” Accompanied by a Spotify playlist of “forbidden love” anthems and fan art of the duo as tragic lovers, it’s catnip for a fandom still reeling from the trilogy’s October 16, 2025, premiere, which clocked 180 million streams in its first month, per Prime Video metrics.

What elevates this from quirky fanfic fodder to full-blown controversy is the shadow of Guevara’s relationship with de Nati. The 29-year-old starlet, whose indie cred from La Mesías contrasts Wallace’s rom-drama dominance, has been Guevara’s anchor since early 2024. Paparazzi snaps of them entwined on Barcelona beaches—post-Culpa Tuya premiere, no less—paint a picture of domestic bliss, with de Nati’s subtle IG likes on his wrap posts screaming “team player.” Yet, the theory’s author doesn’t shy from the drama: “Every touch is a glance María can’t unsee—Gabriel’s playing with fire while she’s waiting off-set.” Replies on the gossip page devolve into chaos: shippers wailing “Let him go to her, but damn, those touches hurt,” while anti-shippers fire back, “Respect boundaries—María deserves better than your delusions.” One viral X thread, compiling the GIFs with de Nati’s red-carpet solos, hit 50,000 likes: “She’s the ghost in the room every time they ‘accidentally’ connect.”

To unpack this obsession, rewind to the trilogy’s genesis. My Fault (Culpa Mía, 2023) wasn’t just a Wattpad adaptation; it was a cultural earthquake, blending Twilight-esque angst with unapologetic steaminess. Wallace’s Noah—a fiery American transplant clashing with Guevara’s brooding racer Nick—ignited global thirst, with their first-kiss scene racking up 500,000 TikTok recreations. Off-screen? The duo was inseparable: joint IG Lives dissecting script twists, beach selfies captioned “Chaos siblings,” and a YouTube Q&A where Wallace playfully fed Guevara churros, their knees knocking under the table. “We vibe like we’ve been stepsibs forever,” Guevara joked in a 2023 EL PAÍS sit-down, his arm draped over her chair. Fans ate it up, birthing #Nicogab overnight—fan cams set to Olivia Rodrigo, AO3 fics topping 10,000 hits, and conspiracy boards pinning “real couple” on every shared latte.

But Your Fault (Culpa Tuya, December 2024) flipped the script—literally and figuratively. Production overlapped with Guevara’s Venice scandal (cleared assault claims from his teens), but the real fault line was personal. Wallace’s November 1, 2023, unfollow—timed with a Story blasting “Good 4 U”—signaled war. Premiere footage went nuclear: her stage exit to dodge a photo op, his stiff solo poses, eye contact rarer than a plot twist. Insiders whispered body-shaming likes from Guevara (“her figure’s not intimate-scene ready,” per leaked comments), jealousy over his flings, and de Nati’s entry as the “cool girl” enforcer. A Reddit deep-dive claims de Nati, fresh off dates with Guevara during Tuya wraps, nixed joint posts: “She saw the shipping as a threat—fair, but it iced Nicole out.” By premiere night, Mercedes Ron (the author) stood awkwardly between them, her tweet “Everyone’s guilty” going meta.

Culpa Nuestra demanded reconciliation—on and off screen. Filmed amid the feud’s frost, the script’s time-jump reunion forced proximity: tearful confessions, a rain-soaked embrace that Variety hailed as “visceral.” Behind-the-scenes leaks show the thaw: a TikTok of them rehearsing a make-up scene, hands clasping “for authenticity,” laughter bubbling over takes. Enter the touches. The theory’s “evidence” draws from smuggled BTS reels: Touch #2 during a pool dip (his palm on her back, “steadying” her dive); #4 in a kitchen spat (fingers brushing props, eyes locking post-yell). “These moments scream unresolved tension,” the post argues, cross-referencing with Nuestra‘s plot—Nick’s new flame mirroring de Nati’s shadow. Fans on X amplified it: one thread timestamps all six, overlaying heart-rate audio for “tension peaks,” earning 30,000 retweets. “Accidental? Please—it’s the fault line cracking,” quipped @mercyonangel, whose clip of Guevara’s improvised “Te quiero” (not scripted, per trivia) went viral.

De Nati’s role? The theory’s villain origin. Absent from Ibiza wrap parties (Guevara attended solo), she’s cast as the silent sentinel: “Likes his posts, skips his premieres—knows the touches aren’t accidents.” A gossip page poll—”Is María the real Noah rival?”—tallied 60% yes, with comments like “She’s secure, but those glances? Betrayal fuel.” De Nati’s silence speaks volumes; her Barcelona theater run post-premiere dodged press, but a subtle Story repost of Guevara’s GQ feature (“Loyalty over rumors”) hints at steel. Shippers counter with “protective queen” edits, but the hurt lingers: “Every touch stabs her in effigy.”

The fandom’s response? A schism. On r/Culpables, the theory thread hit 8,000 upvotes, with users compiling “touch timelines” synced to the soundtrack. TikToks recreate the moments with body doubles, captions pleading “Give us the real story.” But backlash brews: “This invades privacy—María’s not your plot device,” tweeted @LaQuisquillossa, her post on the duo’s post-trilogy silence racking 3,000 likes. Darker still, harassment resurfaces—Wallace’s DMs flooded with “homewrecker” barbs, echoing 2024’s toll that sent her to therapy, per Variety. Guevara, in a post-premiere ELLE chat, deflected: “Nicole’s a pro—touches are acting, nothing more.” Wallace, promo-weary, told Collider: “Fans see what they want; we’re just telling a story.”

Professionally, the trilogy’s a triumph: Nuestra snagged MTV Europe nods for chemistry, despite the irony. Wallace, 23, dives into Netflix’s Echoes thriller, her Noah vulnerability earning “breakout” buzz. Guevara, 24, eyes indies with de Nati, their Barcelona sightings a quiet rebuttal. Yet, the theory endures—a leaked artifact of shipping’s double blade, where six touches symbolize everything unsaid. As one X poet mused: “Accidents or fate? With her watching, every graze is a fault line.” In Culpables‘ echo, fans cling to the sparks, but at what cost to the stars’ real lives? The touches may fade, but the scandal? Eternal.