‘Sullivan’s Crossing’ Season 4: The Secret Affair That Will Change EVERYTHING 🌙🔥
Whispers of a forbidden romance have begun to circulate… and when the truth explodes, no relationship will be safe.

‘Sullivan’s Crossing’ Season 4: The Secret Affair That Will Change EVERYTHING 🌙🔥

The heartfelt drama of Sullivan’s Crossing, adapted from Robyn Carr’s beloved novels, has captivated audiences with its mix of romance, family secrets, and small-town tensions. As Season 3 ended on June 22, 2025, with a jaw-dropping cliffhanger—Maggie Sullivan’s secret husband, Liam, crashing back into her life—fans are buzzing about what’s next for the residents of this picturesque Nova Scotia campground. With Season 4 confirmed for a 2026 premiere on The CW and CTV, whispers of a forbidden romance have ignited speculation across social media platforms like X. This secret affair, teased by showrunner Roma Roth as a “game-changer,” promises to upend relationships and reshape the narrative. Here’s a deep dive into the affair that could redefine Sullivan’s Crossing—and why no one will emerge unscathed when the truth comes out.

The Setup: A Town Ripe for Secrets

Season 3 left Sullivan’s Crossing in turmoil. Maggie (Morgan Kohan) was blindsided by Liam’s (Marcus Rosner) return, threatening her budding romance with Cal Jones (Chad Michael Murray). Sully (Scott Patterson) departed for Ireland with his new love interest, Helen, leaving the campground’s future uncertain. Meanwhile, characters like Lola, Sydney, Rafe, and Rob faced their own personal crossroads. Against this backdrop of emotional upheaval, Season 4’s rumored affair introduces a spark that could ignite the entire community. But who’s involved, and why does it matter? The stakes are higher than ever, as this forbidden romance could fracture friendships, betrayals, and family ties.

The Prime Suspects: Who’s Behind the Affair?

While no official details have been confirmed, fan theories and subtle hints from the cast point to several possible culprits. One compelling scenario involves Sydney (Lindura) and Rafe (Tom Jackson). Their close friendship has always carried an undercurrent of tension, and with Rafe’s marriage to Edna showing signs of strain in Season 3, a secret romance could explain their lingering glances. Sydney’s independent spirit and Rafe’s quiet intensity make them an intriguing pair, but an affair would devastate Edna and ripple through the tight-knit campground community.

Another possibility centers on Lola (Amalia Williamson) and Jacob, her long-distance love interest introduced in Season 3. Jacob’s arrival in Sullivan’s Crossing could stir jealousy or temptation, especially if Lola reconnects with a local like Finn, Rob’s son. A forbidden fling here would not only complicate Lola’s arc but also strain her relationship with her father, Roy, and the Shandons.

The wild card? Cal himself. While his devotion to Maggie is clear, Liam’s return might push him toward an unexpected connection—perhaps with a new character, like one of the “shady new neighbors” teased for Season 4. A moment of weakness could lead Cal into a secret affair, shattering Maggie’s trust and setting the stage for a love triangle with seismic consequences.

Why This Affair Changes Everything

Unlike past romantic entanglements in Sullivan’s Crossing, this affair is poised to be more than a fleeting plot point. Posts on X suggest fans expect a betrayal that “cuts deeper” than Maggie’s hidden marriage or Andrew’s manipulations in earlier seasons. Here’s why this secret romance could redefine the show:

Fractured Trust: If Sydney and Rafe are involved, Edna’s heartbreak would test her resilience and alter her role as the campground’s emotional anchor. Similarly, a Cal-related affair would devastate Maggie, forcing her to question her future at the Crossing.

Community Fallout: The small-town setting amplifies the impact of personal betrayals. An affair involving core characters like Lola or Sydney could divide loyalties, pitting friends and family against each other.

Maggie’s Breaking Point: Already grappling with Liam’s return and her medical career, Maggie could be pushed to her limits if the affair involves someone close to her, like Cal or Sydney. This could force her to confront her own vulnerabilities and make life-altering decisions.

New Dynamics: The affair could introduce fresh alliances or rivalries, especially if new characters are involved. The rumored “time jump” in Season 4 might reveal the affair’s aftermath, showing how relationships have shifted in its wake.

The Emotional Stakes: Who Gets Hurt?

No affair in Sullivan’s Crossing would come without collateral damage. If Rafe and Sydney cross the line, Edna’s trust in both her husband and her friend would be shattered, potentially isolating her from the community. A Lola-Jacob-Finn triangle would hurt Roy and Rob, complicating their roles as parental figures. If Cal strays, Maggie’s arc—already strained by Liam’s return—could take a darker turn, pushing her away from the Crossing altogether. Fans on X are vocal about their fears: one user posted, “If Cal betrays Maggie, I’m done. Their chemistry is the heart of the show!” Yet others argue a betrayal could deepen the drama, forcing characters to grow through pain.

Should the Affair Happen?

The idea of a forbidden romance is divisive. Some fans crave the chaos, believing it will elevate the show’s emotional depth and mirror the messy realities of small-town life. Others worry it risks alienating viewers who are invested in established relationships, like Maggie and Cal’s slow-burn romance. The affair’s success will depend on its execution—Roth and her team must balance shock value with character-driven storytelling. If the affair feels organic and ties into the show’s themes of forgiveness and redemption, it could be a masterstroke. If it feels forced or overly melodramatic, it might push fans away.

What Else to Expect in Season 4

Set to film in Halifax, Nova Scotia, starting in August 2025, Season 4 will span 10 episodes and premiere in mid-2026. The season will dive deeper into Maggie’s pursuit of her Canadian medical license, Cal’s response to Liam’s bombshell, and Sully’s new life in Ireland. The introduction of new neighbors and a possible time jump suggests fresh faces and shifted dynamics, with the affair serving as a catalyst for change. With Season 3’s success on Netflix’s Top 10, the pressure is on to deliver a season that balances romance, drama, and heart.

How to Watch

When Season 4 airs, it will be available on CTV in Canada and The CW in the U.S., with next-day streaming on The CW app. Netflix is expected to release the full season a few months after its finale, likely in late 2026. Fans can catch up on Seasons 1-3 on Netflix or The CW app to brace for the emotional rollercoaster ahead.

Final Thoughts

The secret affair teased for Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4 has the potential to be a defining moment for the series. Whether it involves Sydney and Rafe, Lola and a new love, or even Cal himself, this forbidden romance will test loyalties and reshape relationships in ways no one can predict. As whispers of betrayal spread through the Crossing, one thing is clear: when the truth explodes, no one will be safe. Fans are counting down to 2026, ready to see how this scandal unfolds—and who will pick up the pieces.