In the digital coliseum of social media, where every like, follow, and unfollow is dissected like ancient hieroglyphs, the Culpables trilogy’s leads have dropped a bombshell that rivals the saga’s most explosive plot twists. Nicole Wallace, 23, and Gabriel Guevara, 24—the on-screen stepsibling lovers whose forbidden passion in Amazon Prime Video’s My Fault, Your Fault, and now Our Fault has amassed over 150 million global streams—were spotted unfollowing each other on Instagram in a strikingly synchronized purge on November 1, 2023. After two years of effusive online camaraderie that had fans scripting their real-life romance, this mutual digital divorce has reignited the feud frenzy. But here’s the shocker: Digital sleuths and set insiders align the cutoff with a mysterious five-day filming hiatus during Your Fault production, rumored to have been a pressure-cooker of backstage blowups. As #GabiColeBreakup trends anew amid Our Fault‘s October 16, 2025, release, fans are wild—divided between heartbroken shippers and conspiracy theorists. Was this the end of an era, or the spark of deeper discord? 🔥

The unfollow saga unfurled like a slow-motion car crash on November 1, 2023, mere weeks after My Fault‘s June premiere had cemented Wallace and Guevara as Hollywood’s hottest “just friends.” From their 2018 debut sparks on El Internado: Las Cumbres—where a 16-year-old Wallace and 17-year-old Guevara bonded over auditions—to the trilogy’s 2022 casting, their Instagram feeds were a love letter to synergy. Joint Stories from Marbella beaches, Guevara’s “talisman” captions under Wallace’s posts, her shoutouts in ELLE España: “Gabriel’s warmth is the heart of it all.” Fans ate it up—#GabiCole edits flooded TikTok, racking millions of views with “endgame” overlays. Chloe Guevara’s October 20, 2023, snaps of the duo cozy at a fair? Peak camaraderie, with Guevara even purging ex-follows and adding Wallace’s fave, Sabrina Carpenter, to his grid. “Two years of this glow? Then poof—gone,” lamented @josephinehero in a December 2024 X thread, her video of archived posts hitting 7,118 likes and 401,630 views.

But at 2:17 AM on November 1, the idyll imploded. Wallace struck first, unfollowing Guevara and archiving joint pics, her Stories erupting in cryptic clips of raging storms and heartbreak anthems—Billie Eilish’s “What Was I Made For?” on loop. Hours later, Guevara reciprocated: Unfollow, mass-delete of their photos, even scrubbing his comments from her profile. “Simultaneous? Nah, but synced like a bad duet—early hours, same day, zero overlap left,” digital analyst @m_r_r0601 broke it down in a December 2024 X post, threading timestamps with 1,200 likes and forensic screenshots: Wallace at 2:17 AM, Guevara by dawn. By Christmas 2023, the purge was total—Guevara unfollowing Wallace outright, per Threads deep-dives. Fans went feral: “After 2 years of thirst traps and tags? This is murder,” @culpablesachiev raged in a January 2025 thread, 259 likes strong, pinning it to “unfixed wounds snowballing.”

Enter the five-day filming break: The unfollow’s eerie alignment with a late-October 2023 production pause during Your Fault shoots has “digital analysts”—fan-run IG metrics trackers and set-leak aggregators—screaming conspiracy. Culpa Tuya filming kicked off post-My Fault buzz, but whispers of tension simmered early. Insiders via @the.bosswives on Threads claim the hiatus, slotted October 27-November 1, was no rest—it was a “cool-off” mandated after escalating spats over intimacy scene choreography and script fidelity to Ron’s Wattpad roots. “Break for ‘logistics,’ but really? Arguments galore—shouting matches, Gabriel storming off, director Domingo González playing referee,” a crew leak to FandomWire detailed in October 2025, tying the dates to the unfollow. @m_r_r0601’s X explainer amplified: “Testigos en el rodaje” (set witnesses) described a blowup where Guevara snapped, “It’s always the same with you,” during a rehearsal dust-up, the clip viewed 473,885 times. Rumors swirled of a Marbella party clash: Guevara and co-star Víctor Rasuk spotted with his ex Nuria (Guevara’s rumored flame), mutual follows spiking as Wallace’s Stories darkened. “5 days of radio silence? That’s when the tea brewed—unfollow as the boil-over,” @Daninseries posted in December 2023, 288 likes on Italian X, dubbing it “ai ferri corti” (at daggers drawn).

Theories? A fan-fueled maelstrom. Shippers mourn a squandered romance: “2 years of flirty DMs and beach hangs? Break arguments killed the vibe—jealousy over Nuria, or his Venice shadow?” Reddit’s r/VindictaRateCelebs dissected in January 2025, 115 upvotes on claims Guevara body-shamed Wallace (“Not seductive enough for kisses”) and deleted pics post-María de Nati’s jealousy. @culpablesachiev’s January 2025 post: “MDN’s comment led to Nicole blocking Gabi—poster vanished again,” 259 likes fueling “gf interference” lore. Cynics eye toxicity: “Arguments during break? Power plays—his likes on shaming posts, her feminism rants as shade,” per BollywoodShaadis’ October 2025 timeline, where Wallace’s post-unfollow ELLE chat on “respect” screamed subtext. Digital tools like SocialBlade tracked the sync: “Mutual at peak feud—November 1 dip in mutual engagement post-break,” analysts on r/Fauxmoi noted in December 2024, 78 upvotes debating “gf-forced distance.”

Fallout? A frost that froze the franchise. By Your Fault‘s December 2024 premiere, avoidance was art: Wallace fleeing stage photos, eyes averted in split-screen Q&As. “Good working relationship,” Wallace demurred to The Direct; Guevara’s “friends, but working” rang hollow. Our Fault filming? Tense thaws—script clashes, that rain whisper (our chemistry explode)—but promos stayed siloed, no joint posts till a forced October 2025 vid where awkward sofa sits sparked “still feuding?” rumors. @NiyWallace72248, her fan page, pleads sanity across November 2025 posts: “Nobody knows their story—no demons, just hurt; cast still loves ’em as siblings,” tallying 0-9 likes amid wars.

Fans? A wildfire of wild. @culpablesachiev’s December 2024 Prime insider vid—”confirmations” of the break blowup—hit 463 likes, 170,990 views, threading “yelling matches” with English subs. Shippers remix: “Unfollow after arguments? Plot twist for Our Fault sequel,” @fandomwire echoed in October 2025. Defenders flip: @josephinehero’s reminder—”He deleted everything, not her”—7,118 likes slamming “unprofessional” tags on Wallace. That November 14 café meet (reunion rumble)? Now “post-unfollow therapy,” with @Christi16930994 speculating: “5-day arguments led here—heal, kids!” 212 likes. Critics like Distractify (December 2024) hail the irony: “From friends to nothing—Hollywood’s cruelest unfollow.”

Wallace, prepping The House of Spirits, and Guevara, indie-bound, carry the ghosts. In Ron’s realm, faults birth fire; off-grid, this simultaneous snub—timed to a break of rumored rage—proves fans’ wildest fears: Camaraderie crumbled, but the chemistry? Eternal echo. As Our Fault surges to 25 million views, the unfollow lingers—a digital scar from a five-day storm.