DIABOLICAL — and the timeline refuses to line up

Sources allege Mike McKee was scheduled to stay overnight at the hospital on Dec 29, with a cot reserved — just hours before Spencer and Monique Tepe were found gone in the early morning of Dec 30. The claim says his phone was left behind in the cot room while he allegedly disappeared for a ~14-hour round trip, then returned to clock in at 11:00 a.m. as if the night never happened.

Days later, federal agents reportedly contacted the hospital on Jan 8 and Jan 9 seeking records of his whereabouts. On Jan 8, he was allegedly inside the operating room — aligning with a family’s account of a 10-hour surgery performed by him that same day.

The arrest followed on Saturday, Jan 10, at a Chick-fil-A in Rockford.

All details remain alleged. McKee faces two counts of aggravated, premeditated murder and is presumed innocent.
Investigators continue to focus on a single hospital timestamp — one entry that does not match the rest of the night.

**********************************

DIABOLICAL ALLEGATIONS: Unpacking Claims of Michael McKee’s Alleged Alibi-Busting Timeline in the Tepe Double Murder Case

The shocking double homicide of Spencer Tepe, a 37-year-old respected dentist, and his wife Monique Tepe, 39, in their Columbus, Ohio home on December 30, 2025, has gripped the nation with its chilling domestic undertones and the rapid arrest of Monique’s ex-husband, Michael David McKee, a 39-year-old vascular surgeon. McKee was taken into custody on January 10, 2026, at a Chick-fil-A in Rockford, Illinois, and charged with two counts of premeditated aggravated murder. Authorities have described the attack as “targeted” and “domestic violence-related,” with evidence including neighborhood surveillance footage, vehicle tracking, and a firearm preliminarily linked to the crime scene recovered from McKee’s property.

McKee, who was married to Monique from 2015 to 2017 (divorcing after about two years amid allegations of incompatibility and emotional abuse from family statements), has waived extradition and is expected to face trial in Ohio, where aggravated murder carries the possibility of life imprisonment or the death penalty. He has indicated through his public defender that he intends to plead not guilty.

Here are key images from the investigation and aftermath, illustrating the crime scene and public response:

This photograph shows the Tepe family home in Columbus’s Weinland Park neighborhood, cordoned off with police tape after the bodies were discovered on December 30, 2025.

Another somber image captures the exterior of the residence, where tributes of flowers and candles have since appeared in memory of Spencer and Monique.

The Chilling Timeline Allegations

A source has alleged a highly provocative scenario regarding McKee’s movements around the time of the murders, which occurred in the early morning hours of December 30 (police have indicated the killings took place around 3:52 a.m.). According to this unverified account:

McKee reportedly worked a shift on December 29 at OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center in Rockford, Illinois (approximately 90 miles west of Chicago, where he was employed as a vascular surgeon).
He allegedly reserved a cot in a hospital “cot room” (a designated rest area for on-call staff) to spend the night there.
The source claims he left his cellphone in the cot room that evening — potentially as a deliberate attempt to create an appearance of presence — before leaving the hospital.
He then purportedly drove roughly 7 hours (about 450 miles) to Columbus, Ohio, committed the murders, and returned the same distance (a round trip of approximately 14 hours).
He allegedly clocked back in at the hospital around 11 a.m. on December 30, resuming work as if nothing had happened.

This narrative, if substantiated, would represent an extraordinary feat of premeditation and stamina — driving nearly 900 miles round-trip in a short window while committing a double homicide. The source further alleges that when federal authorities contacted the hospital on January 8 and 9 seeking information on McKee’s whereabouts, he was reportedly in surgery performing a lengthy procedure (coinciding with a relative’s claim of a 10-hour operation overseen by McKee on January 8).

Here are visuals related to McKee’s arrest and the investigation’s key evidence:

This frame from surveillance footage released by Columbus police shows a person of interest walking in a nearby alley in the early morning hours of December 30, wearing a dark hooded jacket — later linked to McKee through vehicle and other evidence.

Another image depicts the arrest scene in Rockford, Illinois, where McKee was taken into custody at a Chick-fil-A on January 10, 2026.

These details remain alleged and unconfirmed by official sources. Mainstream reporting (from outlets like Columbus Dispatch, NBC News, USA Today, and ABC News) has not corroborated the cot room, cellphone, or exact work schedule claims. Instead, confirmed elements include:

McKee’s employment at OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center in Rockford, where the hospital stated it is cooperating with authorities.
Surveillance video showing a person matching McKee’s description near the Tepe home.
Vehicle tracking placing his car in the area before and after the estimated time of death.
Multiple firearms seized from his property, with one preliminarily matched to evidence at the scene via ballistic analysis.
No signs of forced entry at the home, and the couple’s two young children (ages 1 and 4) found unharmed alongside the family dog.

The timeline allegations, if true, would suggest an extraordinarily calculated effort to establish a false presence at work while committing the crimes. However, without official confirmation, they remain speculative and part of the broader online discussion surrounding the case.

Here are additional images from memorials honoring Spencer and Monique Tepe:

This photograph shows a vigil with candles, flowers, and portraits of the couple, as the community grieves the loss of two devoted parents.

Another emotional scene from a celebration of life event, where friends and family gathered to remember Spencer and Monique’s warmth and love for their family.

Broader Context and Ongoing Investigation

The Tepe murders unfolded when Spencer’s colleagues called for a wellness check after he failed to appear for work — an uncharacteristic absence. Officers discovered the couple shot dead upstairs, with no weapon found at the scene and no signs of theft or struggle beyond the shootings. Police ruled out murder-suicide early on.

Family statements have painted a picture of Monique’s fear during her short marriage to McKee, with her brother-in-law describing her as “terrified” and willing to do anything to escape the relationship. McKee has no prior criminal history mentioned in reports, though he faced a medical malpractice lawsuit filed in 2024 (related to a 2023 procedure in Las Vegas), which alleged negligence leading to injury and emergency surgery for a patient.

Here are images reflecting the national attention and calls for justice:

This visual shows a protest or vigil sign demanding accountability, amid widespread media coverage of the case.

A tribute photo of Spencer Tepe in his dental practice, highlighting his reputation as a devoted professional and father.

Authorities have emphasized they believe McKee is the responsible party, backed by substantial evidence. He remains in custody in Illinois pending extradition to Ohio, with his next court appearance scheduled for January 23, 2026, in Winnebago County.

All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The allegations regarding McKee’s work schedule, cellphone, and overnight movements are unverified and should be treated as such pending official disclosure or trial evidence.

The Tepe family continues to grieve, surrounded by community support, as they seek justice for two lives taken far too soon.