The timeline has changed — and with it, the entire investigation.

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police have now confirmed that the last verified sighting of Lilly Sullivan and Jack Sullivan occurred on May 1, 2025 — not May 2, as previously reported.

The correction reveals a critical gap: a full 24-hour period during which neither was being actively searched for.

A One-Day Error With Major Consequences

Police say the updated timeline emerged after investigators re-evaluated witness statements and supporting information.

That adjustment may seem minor on paper, but in missing-person cases, every hour matters. A full day can dramatically affect search strategies, evidence preservation, and the chances of locating those involved.

The Missing 24 Hours

With the revised date, investigators are now focused on what happened during the unaccounted-for day.

Where were Lilly and Jack during that time?
Who, if anyone, saw them?
And why did the search not begin sooner?

Police have not yet provided detailed answers but confirmed the gap is now central to the case.

Why the Delay?

RCMP officials acknowledged the discrepancy but have not publicly explained why the earlier date was not identified sooner.

Investigators are reviewing how the initial timeline was constructed and what information may have led to the delay.

Rebuilding the Investigation

The corrected timeline means detectives must now revisit earlier assumptions.

Search areas, witness lists, and digital records are being re-examined in light of the new information. Investigators say the process is ongoing and methodical.

What Changes Now

Experts note that missing even 24 hours can alter the trajectory of an investigation.

Environmental conditions, travel distance, and digital activity can all change significantly in a single day, potentially opening new lines of inquiry — or closing others.

No Conclusions Yet

RCMP emphasized that the timeline correction does not point to a specific outcome.

Lilly and Jack remain missing, and the investigation continues. Authorities urge the public not to speculate and to report any relevant information.

A Case Reset

For investigators, the case now requires a partial reset — a careful reconstruction of events beginning on May 1, not May 2.

For families and communities following the case, the confirmation raises difficult questions about what might have happened during the hours no one knew were missing.

One thing is clear: those 24 hours now matter more than ever.