Deception, blame, cloud motive in killing of CT girl whose body was hidden for year, documents show

NEW BRITAIN, Conn. (WTNH) — Just weeks after an 11-year-old Jacqueline “Mimi” Torres-Garcia’s body was found at an abandoned New Britain Home, new details are being brought to light about interactions police had with the child’s family months before.

On Dec. 29, 2024, Farmington police were called to the home of Karla Garcia and Jonatan Nanita for a noise complaint. A few minutes later, Garcia comes to the door stating that everything is okay, although the neighbors are “always calling.”

10 months after this interaction, Garcia and Nanita were arrested and charged with murdering Karla’s 11-year-old daughter.

During the interaction, neither Garcia nor Nanita mentions that Jacqueline had been missing.

Former Fairfield police chief Gary MacNamara said this uncovered valuable information.

“We have the ability to now understand all the facts and circumstances,” he said. “These officers have no clue, zero clue, how many kids are in the house or the fact that there may be a body in the basement; they have no information.”

According to the arrest warrants, Jacqueline’s father tried multiple times to see his daughter, but was kept away. When trying to conduct wellness checks, officials had no idea where Karla Garcia was living after she moved out of her Farmington apartment.

For more on the story, watch the full video in the player above.

New Britain Police Department

Arrest warrants for the mother and her then-boyfriend detail their conflicting stories about the homeschooled girl’s final weeks of life, circumstances surrounding her death, and their attempted disposal of her body.

Warning: This story contains graphic details of child abuse and its aftermath.

More information about the shocking story behind the body of a 11-year-old girl found after it had been dumped behind an abandoned house in Connecticut were revealed along with the arrest warrants for the two defendants in the case.

Much of the information, though, cannot be taken strictly as fact as both parties have been pointing the finger at the other and have shared vastly different stories with authorities about just what happened up to and beyond the death of Jacqueline “Mimi” Torres-Garcia.

Both the girl’s mother, Karla Garcia, 29, and her then-boyfriend — Jonatan Nanita, 30, who is not the child’s father — have been charged with murder for the death of Torres-Garcia, which investigators have determined occurred at some point in the fall of 2024.

Garcia and Nanita share three other children, per NBC Connecticut. Garcia also had another child with the victim’s father.

The father spoke with police on October 11, 2025, where he told them that his mother had had primary custody of Jacqueline until she was eight or nine years old, due to both parents being incarcerated immediately after her birth, and that by 2017, she had custody of both of their daughters together.

After his 2020 release, he shared joint custody until 2023, when Garcia got full custody and, he said, “made it very difficult to see his children.” He said the last time that he saw his eldest daughter, Jacqueline, was her fifth-grade graduation on June 10, 2024.

When he attended his younger daughter’s fifth-grade graduation on June 9, 2025, he was told Jacqueline was at school, per the affidavits, but she was already deceased. He also said there were always excuses when he would ask to speak with her or show up to see her, with Garcia telling him she was at school, with friends, or visiting relatives.

Police didn’t become aware of the case until the girl’s body was found in a storage “tote” behind the abandoned house in New Britain on October 8 of this year.

The arrest warrants, as detailed by Law&Crime and viewable via WFSB here, reveal how the girl’s body was found inside the tote, describing that she “was folded at the waist with the legs curled up against the torso and knees facing the skull.” Additionally, “the skin appeared to be glued to the bones,” the report states, with the note that this detail is significant because it was another indication of her suffering before death.

“The condition of the corpse was due to severe malnourishment, not decomposition,” the affidavit states, with police asserting that Torres-Garcia suffered “prolonged physical abuse and malnourishment prior to her death.” Her body reportedly weighed 26 to 27 pounds when found.

Additionally, police believe the pre-teen was murdered in the town of Farmington and then her body was transported with the family when they moved to New Berlin in March. Prior to that, police believe the body was kept “in the family’s basement.” Her death went unnoticed for so long, officials believe, because she was being homeschooled.

Karla Garcia’s Story

When speaking with police, Garcia told them that her daughter died “sometime in her bed, but she wasn’t sure exactly when,” according to the affidavit. She said that she just remembers Nanita “came downstairs one day and told her that Jacqueline Torres-Garcia ‘was not breathing anymore.”

Garcia said that after telling her, Nanita moved Torres-Garcia’s body to the basement, but she never went down there to see what he’d done with her. She knew the body was down there, though, because she admitted that eventually the smell got so bad in the house that they “began to stay at hotels and with other friends.”

When originally questioned by police, per the warrant, Garcia said that her daughter “was fine, and visiting a friend.” But that story didn’t hold up very long. She later admitted that she and the 11-year-old had been arguing over Garcia being pregnant a third time with Nanita. She told investigators that her daughter “was upset that she was pregnant again.”

“She stated that during the argument Jacqueline pushed her down the stairs inside her house causing both of them to fall down the stairs,” the affidavit states, with Garcia claiming that Nanita “became upset” with the 11-year-old and allegedly “kicked her in the head, and dragged her off.”

According to the girls’ mother, she “never saw her daughter again after that.” Additionally, she “denied any knowledge of the tote containing her daughter.”

Jonatan Nanita’s Story

When police spoke with Nanita, they got a very different story, though, with the boyfriend claiming he’d been kicked out of Garcia’s house at the apparent time of the pre-teen’s death, according to his arrest warrant.

He said he was “homeless after Garcia kicked him out” in August and was shocked when he walked into her house after she contacted him to “dispose” of a tote at her apartment building. He told police that he “walked into the home and saw blood all over the walls, along the staircase,” per the report.

When he asked what happened, he said he was told “they didn’t know … and Torres-Garcia was missing,” per the affidavit. Nanita said he “panicked and left the apartment without knowing what happened.”

The next day, Nanita said he returned to the apartment “and the blood was cleaned up.” According to his version of events, “he never saw Jacqueline Torres-Garcia again and they never talked about what happened.”

Admissions of Abuse

Investigators revealed that there were no signs of trauma or injury on Torres-Garcia’s body that would have contributed to her death, nor were there signs that there had been any internal bleeding.

Nevertheless, Garcia and Nanita, as well as Garcia’s sister, Jackelyn Garcia, all admitted to taking part in the abuse of Torres-Garcia in the house. According to the girl’s mother, she and Nanita would “mistreat” the girl because she was “bad, she didn’t listen, she didn’t respect them,” per the warrant.

Garcia told police that the 11-year-old was “doing things she wasn’t supposed to do, including striking other kids, going into people’s cars, and having five boyfriends.” Ultimately she admitted that “they stopped giving Jacqueline food for about two weeks prior to her death.”

Jackelyn told police what she allegedly witnessed while living with the couple temporarily before Torres-Garcia’s death. She detailed “seeing her niece zip tied on a couple of occasions,” according to her own warrant. When asked how long the girl had been deprived of food, Jackelyn said “she did not know but that when she last saw her, she was already skinny.”

Additionally, she told police that the girl “was always in the corner of the house and that the zip ties started at the ‘end.'” According to the arrest warrant, Jackelyn took pictures of Torres-Garcia while she was “zip-tied, severely malnourished, and laying on dog pee pads to use as a bathroom.”

Jackelyn detailed one alleged incident where the girl “peed or defecated herself” while in this position, per the report, and Jackelyn “watched Jonatan pick her up by her shoulders and bring her downstairs.” She said Nanita hit the girl and she could hear her crying, according to the affidavit.

Body Disposal

Jackelyn told police that while she had nothing to do with the girl’s death, she said she was aware of the “tote” containing her body in the basement. She said that her sister told her that Nanita “moved the bin with his Acura,” and later said he “had to get rid of the bin because it was beginning to smell in the car,” according to her warrant.

She also told police that Garcia had told her when her daughter died, saying it happened on September 19, 2024, per search warrants for their phones previously released and reported on by WFSB.

As detailed in Nanita’s arrest warrant, he told police that he was acting under Garcia’s instructions when he loaded the bin into his truck and “drove to a nearby cemetery to hide the tote.” Jackelyn told police that she and Garcia’s “mother is buried in this cemetery” and was “dug up,” per the affidavit.

Nanita, however, said that he couldn’t find a good location to dispose of the “tote” at the cemetery, so he instead drove to the abandoned building where it would ultimately be found, dumping Torres-Garcia’s body, still in the container, into the backyard.

Initially, when asked by police who was in the bin, Nanita said he did not know, per the affidavit. When asked again, “he shrugged and said, ‘I haven’t seen Jacqueline.'” After this, he was asked if he knew it was Torres-Garcia in the bin and he said yes.

Nanita’s new girlfriend also spoke with police, saying she remembered him “driving to a cemetery, picking up a tote, putting the tote in the trunk of the Acura, then driving to 80 Clark St. where he removed the tote from the trunk and placed it at that location.”

She did not, however, know what was in it at the time, she said, though she noted that it “smelled bad.” She told investigators that “after thinking about it, [she] believed that the tote may have contained a body and told her friends.”

Murder Investigation

According to police, Nanita was spotted dumping the container, which ultimately would lead to their investigation, the arrests of Nanita and the Garcia sisters, and the charges brought against them.

Authorities received an anonymous tip about the body, with the tipster reportedly telling them that “Nanita had picked up a tote in the woods of a cemetery and put it in the back of his car,” per WFSB, before driving to the abandoned property and leaving the tote there, per the warrant. The tipster told police they believed the tote contained a body.

The body was found by police on October 8, 2025 and later that same day, they interviewed Jackelyn. She said that she lived with her sister and her sister’s boyfriend in Farmington from June 2024 to August 2024, per the warrants, sharing a room with Torres-Garcia and another child.

She shared that in addition to witnessing the girl abused and zip-tied in the corner, Torres-Garcia had attempted to escape and run away on two separate occasions that she was aware of, only to be brought home by a family member each time. The girl was subsequently restrained with zip ties in punishment, Jackelyn told investigators.

Jackelyn moved out in August 2024, she said, telling police that she knew that Torres-Garcia was going to die under her sister’s care.

WFSB notes that Jackelyn subsequently spent eight months in prison, from December 2024 to August 2025, after she was convicted and charged with abusing her then-11-month-old child. She told police that after her release from prison, she moved back in with Garcia and Nanita, with Garcia acting as her sponsor.

It was after she moved back in, according to the outlet, that Jackelyn discovered her niece’s body. This was when Karla told her when Torres-Garcia had died, according to Jackelyn’s statement to police.

The following day, police spoke with Garcia, who told them her version of the events surrounding her daughter’s death, while also saying that she had been about to go on a podcast to talk about what had happened to her daughter when she was arrested. She said that she had written notes on her phone about what she had been planning to say, according to the warrant.

On October 9, investigators spoke with Garcia-Torres’ younger sister, with whom she shared a father, per the arrest warrant for Garcia. The 11-year-old is reportedly now in the custody of the Department of Children and Families (DCF). According to the affidavit, during their interview, the girl “made no disclosures regarding any incidents of abuse in the house and she did not acknowledge the existence of her older sister Jacqueline Torres-Garcia, only her younger half siblings.”

DCF Involvement

The Connecticut Department of Children and Families told the CT Mirror that they had been involved with the family, but they were unaware of the abuse and death of Torres-Garcia in 2024.

In a statement and timeline released October 17, 2025, the organization said that the family deceived them by having another child impersonate Torres-Garcia in a Zoom welfare check in January of this year. The family told them that she was being homeschooled and visiting a relative out of state at the time, per the news outlet. Police now believe the girl was already deceased.

DCF said in its statement that it had been involved with Torres-Garcia from her birth, which occurred while Karla was in a detention center. The newborn stayed with a relative for the first nine years of her life, until May 2022, when her parents sought guardianship of her and her younger sibling.

Guardianship was granted by the court, and supported by DCF at the time, which has said it often advocates for keeping families together. A subsequent visit i relation to Torres-Garcia’s younger siblings saw DCF interact with her in September 2022, but there was not enough evidence of abuse or neglect and that case was closed in November 2022, per the Mirror.

New Britain Public Schools also issued a statement, per Fox 61, where they said that Karla told them Torres-Garcia was going to be homeschooled and she was pulled from the school system in August 2024, just one month prior to her death.